Bully Sticks vs. Rawhide: Which Is Safer for Your Dog?

As pet parents, we always want the best for our dogs—especially when it comes to their health and safety. One area that often raises concern is what we give our dogs to chew on. Chew treats are important for dogs, not just for fun but also for their dental health. But with so many options available, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. 

Among the most popular dog chews are bully sticks and rawhide. Both are often seen as go-to options for satisfying a dog's chewing needs, but how do you know which one is safer? In this blog, we’ll dive deep into the differences between bully sticks and rawhide, comparing their safety and benefits, so you can make an informed decision for your furry friend. 

Introduction: The Need for Safe Dog Chews 

Dogs love to chew—it's natural behavior. In fact, chewing is not only satisfying for dogs but also beneficial for their mental stimulation and dental health. However, pet parents must be cautious when choosing chew treats, as some can pose serious health risks. 

While bully sticks and rawhide chews have been staples in the pet industry for years, there are concerns about their safety. This is especially true when it comes to rawhide, which has faced increasing scrutiny due to its potential risks. On the other hand, bully sticks have gained popularity as a safer alternative. But are they really the better choice? Let’s explore. 

Understanding the Basics 

Before we can discuss the safety of bully sticks and rawhide, it’s important to understand what each of these chews is and how they are made. 

What Are Bully Sticks? 

Bully sticks are natural dog treats made from the muscle of a cow’s penis (called the pizzle). They’re often dehydrated or baked, making them tough and durable for dogs to chew on. Because bully sticks are 100% beef and contain no artificial additives, they are generally considered to be a safer, more natural option compared to other types of chews. They are easily digestible, which means if your dog manages to swallow a piece, it won’t cause a blockage in their digestive system. 

Bully sticks come in a variety of shapes and sizes, and they can be bought in different thicknesses to suit different dog breeds. They are available in a variety of forms, from straight sticks to braided options, and some even come flavored to make them even more enticing for your dog. 

What Is Rawhide? 

Rawhide, on the other hand, is made from the inner layer of cow or horse hides. The hides are cleaned, processed, and cut into various shapes, including bones, strips, or twists. The chew is then often flavored or treated with preservatives to make it more appealing to dogs. Rawhide is widely available in pet stores and is typically less expensive than other dog chews. 

While it may seem like a great option for dogs, rawhide poses several risks. In its processed form, rawhide can contain harmful chemicals or preservatives that are potentially dangerous for your dog. Additionally, rawhide chews can be difficult for dogs to digest and can lead to choking or digestive issues if large pieces are swallowed. 

Safety First – A Closer Look 

When it comes to chew treats, safety should always be the top priority. Let’s break down the safety aspects of bully sticks and rawhide. 

Bully Stick Safety Explained 

One of the main reasons why bully sticks are considered a safer option is their digestibility. Because they are made from beef muscle, they break down more easily in your dog’s stomach than other chews. This reduces the risk of choking and blockage, a common concern with rawhide. 

Bully sticks are also free of harmful chemicals. Many rawhide treats are treated with chemicals like bleach or preservatives to make them look appealing or last longer. With bully sticks, you don’t have to worry about harmful additives. When choosing bully sticks, it’s important to look for high-quality, all-natural products with no artificial preservatives or additives. 

Another safety benefit of bully sticks is that they can help improve your dog’s dental health. As dogs chew on bully sticks, the friction helps scrape away plaque and tartar, contributing to cleaner teeth and fresher breath. This can help prevent periodontal disease, a common problem among dogs. 

Rawhide Risks 

While rawhide may seem like a fun chew for your dog, it comes with several risks. One of the biggest concerns is its digestibility. Rawhide is a dense, tough material that can be hard for your dog to break down. If your dog swallows a large piece, it can get stuck in their digestive tract, causing a blockage that may require emergency surgery to remove. 

Another issue with rawhide is the chemicals used in processing. In order to make rawhide chews look appealing and last longer, manufacturers often use bleaching agents, preservatives, and other chemicals. These can be harmful to your dog if ingested, and some may even cause allergic reactions or digestive upset. 

Furthermore, rawhide chews are known to break into small, sharp pieces when chewed on for too long, which can pose a choking hazard or injure your dog’s mouth. These small shards may also cause damage to their gums or teeth.